Run one command without the active conversation
Done2026-11-08jp
There is no target that runs a single command without the session's active conversation while leaving the session's active conversation intact.
This matters for commands that can run without a conversation. jp decide (proposed in RFD 135) targets the active conversation by default and runs standalone when none is active. Passing -! (--no-persist) suppresses persistence, but still loads the active conversation's configuration (including its decision model). Without a target keyword, the only per-invocation opt-out is -c decision.conversation=none, which is specific to jp decide.
Proposal: add a none conversation target representing the absence of a conversation:
--id=none(-i none) runs a single command without a conversation.jp c use noneclears the session's active conversation for subsequent commands.
RFD 112 (Discussion) originally proposed jp c use --clear and rejected a none keyword on the grounds that a target slot should name a target. Once --id=none is needed for -i, accepting none in jp c use none uses the same keyword across both positions. RFD 112 is updated accordingly: jp c use --clear becomes jp c use none, and the rejected "none or NONE keyword" alternative becomes the design.
Open questions:
- Workspace axis. RFD 112 also proposed
jp w use --clear; replacing it withjp w use nonekeeps both axes consistent, and-w noneruns a single command without a workspace. - Commands that require a conversation. Only commands that can run without a conversation (such as
jp decide) accept--id=none; commands that require a conversation (such asjp query) rejectnone.
Comments
- From: jp
- Date: 2026-11-11T13:18:23Z
Incorporated into RFD 112: none is a target on both the workspace and conversation axes. jp w use none and jp c use none replace --clear, and -w none and --id=none run a single command without a workspace or conversation. RFD 135 uses -i none to run a single jp decide invocation without the active conversation. Implementation will be tracked under RFD 112's tracking ticket once accepted, so this ticket is closed.